Episode Transcript
Closing the Access Gap: Treating Adult ADHD Across State Lines
Host: Meghan Beier, PhD | Guest: Nicole Groves, PhD
This transcript has been lightly edited for readability. Filler words, false starts, and repeated words have been removed. Words added for clarity appear in [brackets], and [unclear] marks words that could not be made out in the recording.
[0:00] Introduction
Meghan Beier, PhD: Welcome back to Find Empathy. My name is Dr. Meghan Beier, and I'm a clinical psychologist that specializes in multiple sclerosis, disability, and chronic illness. Today's podcast CE course is on a really interesting intersection of topics. It's about access to care for adults with ADHD, but it's also about whether PSYPACT is actually helping to increase access to care.
If you want CEs for listening, please visit learn.findempathy.com. And as a special note, if you are a PSYPACT provider and need those three CEs for your E.Passport renewal, this podcast course will count towards those three annual CEs. So, without further ado, let's get to our interview with Dr. Nicole Groves, a clinician and researcher from University of Washington and Seattle Children's.
[0:58] Welcome and Background
Meghan Beier, PhD: I'd like to welcome Dr. Nicole Groves, acting assistant professor in the Department of Psychiatry and Behavioral Sciences at the University of Washington School of Medicine and an attending psychologist at Seattle Children's Hospital. Her research and clinical work focuses on ADHD in children and adults, spanning executive functioning, emotion regulation, disparities in telehealth-delivered ADHD care, and innovative parent training interventions. She's also an active mentor with the American Professional Society of ADHD and Related Disorders. In this episode, we will discuss her study of adult ADHD care among US PSYPACT psychologists, why a gap in access persists, and what clinicians can do to better serve adults with ADHD.
Nicole, thank you so much for being here. Welcome.
Nicole Groves, PhD: Thank you.
Meghan Beier, PhD: Is there anything else that would be helpful to share about your work, your career, or research?
Nicole Groves, PhD: I don't think so. You captured it pretty well. I have made a jump from mostly basic research in grad school, where I was really looking at those variables of executive functioning and emotion regulation and how they all related, and now I spend most of my time in clinical work or researching active interventions. I've become really interested in this public health angle too, about access and disparity.
Meghan Beier, PhD: Excellent. And do you work mostly with kids, or do you work with adults as well?
Nicole Groves, PhD: Most of my identified patients are children, but because they're children with ADHD, I actually rarely see children unless I'm evaluating them. I typically work with adults, so parents or caregivers of kids with ADHD, many of whom have ADHD themselves. That's a large part of my work.
Meghan Beier, PhD: Yeah, absolutely. I've heard that many parents are undiagnosed but get picked up when their kids come into clinic. Is that right?
Nicole Groves, PhD: Absolutely. I think a really common experience that I'll have as we go through an evaluation of a child, especially if it's a child where they're coming for an evaluation because a teacher or somebody else said, “Hey, I think you should talk to their doctor about this,” is that a lot of times that means that a parent has made it to adulthood maybe with ADHD undetected, or they have that moment where they're like, “Oh, yeah, I guess maybe I do remember being diagnosed with ADHD when I was like eight, and I took some medication or something,” and that was that.
So a lot of times the process of getting their child evaluated can be really illuminating for the adults too.
[4:12] What Is ADHD?
Meghan Beier, PhD: Yeah, absolutely. So before we dive into the paper that you wrote, I just wanted to make sure that our whole audience is on the same page. Can you just very simply describe what ADHD is? How does it present in kids, and is there any different way that it presents in adults?
Nicole Groves, PhD: Yeah. So the cornerstone symptoms of ADHD are that it's a neurodevelopmental disorder, so per the DSM, symptoms have to be present before age 12. A good rule of thumb is that symptoms or impairments are present before about age 16 for those folks who might have either gone undetected or had some really significant protective factors that helped them compensate.
But the core symptoms are inattention, hyperactivity, or impulsivity that presents at a much higher threshold than what we would consider developmentally or culturally appropriate. In adults, inattention can seem like mind wandering when you're supposed to be focused on something, so it may have more of an internal feeling.
It could also look like difficulties with organization or time management or keeping appointments. You might notice that people are less attentive in conversation, for example. Hyperactivity is one of the places where it looks quite a bit different. Whereas a five-year-old with ADHD might be literally climbing on the furniture or running down the hallway in the clinic, an adult with ADHD might describe more of an internal feeling of restlessness.
They may overschedule themselves and be one of those people that is just always on the go, always doing something. And then impulsivity can manifest a little bit differently. There's certainly still the verbal impulsivity of maybe talking over people, blurting out, saying things that they wish they hadn't.
You can also see impulsivity manifest in some of those core impairments, like spending your paycheck as soon as you get it and not having a lot of savings, or quitting a job as soon as you have a conflict with your boss, or things like that. So the impulsivity can look a little bit different, but the core symptoms are still the same.
[7:11] Emotion Regulation in ADHD
Meghan Beier, PhD: Okay. Just a follow-up question. I work with people living with multiple sclerosis who have executive dysfunction and other kinds of cognitive challenges. One of the things that we talk about a lot is emotion regulation and how that can play out with executive functioning challenges. So how does emotion regulation show up in people living with ADHD?
Nicole Groves, PhD: Yeah. So we know that most adults with ADHD, most kids with ADHD as well, but most adults will have pervasive difficulty with emotion regulation. Some of it is related to executive functioning. There's some evidence that shows us that things like working memory, for example, predict people's ability to regulate their emotion.
What it might look like in real life is a person who is maybe quick-tempered, easy to frustrate, who might have difficulty managing relationships because their emotions are really intense, and they get in the way. One of the ways that I often describe emotion dysregulation in ADHD is that it's often a combination of all gas, no brakes, right?
So you have a gas pedal that's really, really touchy and easy to go zero to 100 really quickly. And then for a lot of folks with ADHD, there's also this difficulty regulating that emotion once it starts. So it's a combination of those two things.
[9:00] Why Adult ADHD Diagnoses Are Increasing
Meghan Beier, PhD: Okay, perfect. So one of the things that I read in, I think it was your paper, is that adult ADHD diagnoses are increasing, and that maybe around 7.8 or 8% of adults are now reporting a lifetime diagnosis. What do you think is driving that increase in diagnoses?
Nicole Groves, PhD: I think there's a lot of things. The timeline of COVID is also important to factor into that surge. If we think about some of the stressors that people were facing during COVID, you may have gone from working in an office that was a really structured setting to working at home and having a lot of that structure removed from you.
You might have had kids that were doing school from home, things like that. So there was objectively an increase in the sorts of tasks that might cause us to really understand or experience inattention at an impairing level for the first time. ADHD has also really taken off on social media.
And it is a deeply relatable disorder, right? These are symptoms that are dimensionally distributed throughout the population, and so all of us to some degree might have difficulty regulating our attention or emotions, and might have some varying degree of impulse control. But when you see something online that's like, “If you do this, this, and this, you might have ADHD,” it's a relatable disorder, and so it becomes easier to question that and suspect that.
So I think there's a couple of things at play. I think the overall field of adult ADHD research is still in its infancy. We know a lot, but we don't know as much as we do maybe about things like the life course of depression, for example.
So there are still some folks where either their ADHD was undetected in childhood, or they thought maybe they'd grown out of it, but they still have those symptoms or impairment at a significant level. So some of it might be that we as clinicians are better at detecting it, and people are better at self-referring.
And some of it might be the other side of it, where that might be a bit inflated if we think about the number of people who are self-reporting a diagnosis that may not have been given to them by a healthcare provider, because ADHD is relatable, and we all just went through a very intensely stressful time as a society, where we would have all had some of those transient symptoms.
[12:28] When a Formal Diagnosis Matters
Meghan Beier, PhD: Yeah. When somebody comes into clinic and maybe they've seen some YouTube videos or TikTok videos about ADHD, and maybe they're self-reporting, and maybe they're seeing their general therapist or their general psychologist, somebody that doesn't necessarily do these assessments, how important is it to refer that person for a more official diagnosis?
Nicole Groves, PhD: Some of it, I think, depends on what you are hoping that either a diagnosis of ADHD or clarity around the diagnosis will provide. If you're already seeing a therapist or a psychologist for therapy, and that's really what you want, somebody to support you with emotion regulation, executive functioning, et cetera, in behavioral treatment, you may not need an official diagnosis.
If you're seeking things like workplace accommodation or medication for ADHD, that would be a place where that differential diagnosis is going to become more important. And with that, I do think one of the pieces here that can be really important is that evaluation also has some of the same barriers to access as CBT does.
But the importance of solid differential diagnosis is hard to overstate here, because the core symptoms of ADHD are some of the most present across disorders in the DSM and also different health conditions and things like that.
[14:36] The PSYPACT Adult ADHD Access Study
Meghan Beier, PhD: Okay, great. I think it's really helpful to discuss treatments, and you mentioned medication versus therapy. But before I get into that, I really want to dive into the paper that you wrote with your colleagues. You published a paper entitled “Disparities in Adult ADHD Care Delivery Among US Telepsychology Providers.” Can you tell me what led to this research study?
Nicole Groves, PhD: Yeah. So Maggie Sibley, who is the principal investigator of the lab and one of the senior authors on the paper, is really interested, along with other members of our team, in this public health access piece of adult ADHD care. This study is intertangled a little bit with the work that our team has done on ADHD coaching and trying to understand the massive boom in that industry.
So what we were suspecting going into this is that psychologists, which was our population for this study, would underserve adults with ADHD. And that is what we ended up finding. We compared psychologists who were advertising services for adults and looked at whether they advertised that they treated anxiety, depression, and/or ADHD.
All of those are disorders with similar prevalence rates and things like that. And what we found is that only about a quarter of psychologists in the PSYPACT directory at the time that we downloaded the information would advertise that they treated adult ADHD at all. And then of those who advertised that they treated adult ADHD and used CBT, it was about 21% of providers.
And those numbers were much higher for depression and anxiety. I think it was around 70% and 75%, respectively.
Meghan Beier, PhD: Okay. And so what do you make of that? Obviously, you can't know all of this, right? With the caveat that maybe more research is needed, what conclusions did you all make from those findings?
Nicole Groves, PhD: Yeah. The primary conclusion there is that obviously there's a gap, right? There's a significant amount of people who are reporting a diagnosis and who are seeking some sort of treatment, and clearly, at least psychologists in this study, we're just not really meeting that demand, at least in terms of the advertised services.
And so obviously more research is needed there. We've done a bit of a follow-up study that isn't published yet, so all of the data are preliminary, but we wanted to get at this from the psychologist point of view. So we surveyed a sub-sample of the folks who were included in this study to look at whether they were willing to treat adults with ADHD as a primary or a comorbid problem, and thinking more about what treatments they used, how they would evaluate, and what hesitancy they had around treating folks with ADHD.
Some of that research is forthcoming, but the main takeaway is that there is still a gap, especially in folks who are willing to treat primary adult ADHD. And a higher proportion of people said that they were willing to treat adult ADHD versus what was advertised.
So there might also be a discrepancy there in terms of what we're willing to do and what we can do versus what we advertise in a way that a prospective client might actually be able to understand and seek our services.
Meghan Beier, PhD: Okay. So maybe people aren't necessarily advertising that they treat ADHD, but they probably could if somebody were to call.
Nicole Groves, PhD: Exactly. Yeah.
[20:06] Evidence-Based Treatments for Adult ADHD
Meghan Beier, PhD: Okay. So given that maybe not everybody has expertise in ADHD, what are the evidence-based treatments for adult ADHD? What does research tell us are ideal treatments for this population?
Nicole Groves, PhD: Yeah. So medication is one option. There's evidence for stimulants and non-stimulants, just like there is in kids. And then cognitive behavioral therapy is the primary evidence-based therapy currently for ADHD. There is some emerging evidence for some third-wave type treatments like mindfulness or DBT skills for folks with ADHD.
I think a lot of us that do CBT in day-to-day practice probably end up merging some of those skills across different modalities. So what I would consider a standard CBT, if you will, is relatively evidence-based for ADHD. Some of the differences are that there might be a heavier component of skill building around some of those executive functioning things like time management, organization, and planning.
But a lot of the core thoughts, emotions, behaviors, and how those things are interconnected and how we change them is very similar. The last evidence-based treatment could be some sort of accommodation. You heard me mention earlier the workplace accommodations. There's also a bit of a difference in adulthood, at least, where for many folks, they can build an environment that they don't necessarily need additional accommodation in.
So it might be your choice of a career or something like that that fits more with your temperament or your symptoms, but accommodations could be one part of the treatment.
Meghan Beier, PhD: Okay. And the CBT part, or CBT plus third-wave therapy. When I'm working with somebody that has multiple sclerosis, for example, a lot of what I'm doing if I'm working with them about cognitive symptoms is things like, if they start to notice a cognitive lapse and they're getting stressed about it, maybe using some of those physiologic deep breathing, relaxation exercises to calm down so that they can think more clearly, not get [unclear], that would be, you know, “I'm so stupid,” or, “Why can't I just do this?” Is that similar for ADHD? Can you tell me a little bit about what some of the common things are that people might be working on in ADHD?
Nicole Groves, PhD: Yeah, absolutely. A lot of it is going to be that self-talk or judgment, especially considering that these are usually folks who have had these symptoms and impairments through most of their life, and they've probably gotten negative feedback from teachers and caregivers and bosses. So some of it is that shame, guilt, maybe anticipatory anxiety about, “I'm not going to be able to do this,” or, “Everybody's going to know that I'm worried about this.”
So there's a combination there of that self-talk, self-judgment piece. Some of it could be the physiological piece as well that you were describing, of noticing symptoms of restlessness, for example, and allowing yourself to recognize that symptom and let it pass, or sit with it even if it's uncomfortable.
The other piece that a lot of folks with ADHD might be working on in therapy is setting up systems or compensatory strategies for some of those core symptoms. So they might be, for example, working on, okay, how do I get my workspace organized to begin with? And then how do I keep up this organizational system over time? Which is usually the real [unclear] for people. But that executive functioning piece and setting up systems might be another crucial point for a lot of folks.
[25:28] Do Psychologists Have the Skills?
Meghan Beier, PhD: And do you feel like most psychologists have that skill? Do they need extra training? What has your research shown, or what's been your experience in that realm?
Nicole Groves, PhD: Yeah, I think for those of us who maybe don't have that skill, you probably have the ability to develop the skill. One of the things that we like to think about is that, especially if you hear those cognitions like, “I'm never going to be good enough at this,” or, “I can't believe I messed that up again. Everybody's watching me. I'm going to do so poorly at this thing,” those sound like a lot of the cognitions that you might deal with with somebody with, quote unquote, run-of-the-mill anxiety or depression. And most of us know what to do with that piece in terms of weighing the evidence and restructuring those thoughts, or managing the emotions that come along with it.
So the executive functioning piece might be one of the places where folks could use some additional support, but I do think that it's likely well within our reach to gain those skills. If you've ever set up an exposure hierarchy for somebody with an anxiety disorder, or if you've ever planned out behavioral activation for somebody with depression, you can probably think through how to systematically approach these executive functioning tasks and gradually increase the demand as you go, as well as how to maintain these systems, right?
So if, for example, you're treating depression, there's always going to be that tendency to lapse back into the depressive symptoms, and so many of us have already worked through how we support folks in maintenance. The other skill that I think is really, really crucial in treating adults with ADHD is feeling at least somewhat confident in your use of MI and your ability to engage with folks that way, and work toward their goals and identify their values and the things that motivate them intrinsically, so that we're not forcing our idea of what it means to be organized or attentive, or to have our schedules managed, onto someone else, but to really think through what they want and what they need to perform in their life.
Meghan Beier, PhD: Okay, excellent. And MI being motivational interviewing.
Nicole Groves, PhD: Yeah.
[28:42] Co-occurring Anxiety and Depression
Meghan Beier, PhD: So you mentioned anxiety and depression. That's bread and butter for most psychologists. How often does that show up in people living with ADHD?
Nicole Groves, PhD: Really frequently. The general rule of thumb is that, especially if they've gotten to adulthood, and especially if they've gotten to adulthood with untreated or undertreated ADHD, the likelihood that there's some sort of comorbidity is incredibly high, and anxiety and depression are two of the most common things, along with things like substance use disorders or autism.
So very common. More often than not, you'll see a comorbidity instead of just pure ADHD.
[29:40] Finding Care Across State Lines
Meghan Beier, PhD: And given that we're talking about PSYPACT, I think one of the goals was to increase care with PSYPACT, right? To be able to have somebody find a psychologist, if people in their area were booked, that they'd be able to find somebody across state lines. How easy is it for somebody to find somebody who specializes in ADHD [or] will treat it in their local area?
Nicole Groves, PhD: Then it gets pretty rough. We looked at the reported home states of the PSYPACT providers that we sifted through, and I think, if I'm remembering correctly, the count was either 26 or 27 of those states or territories had less than one provider per 100,000 residents of that state.
What we ended up finding was that there weren't really any significant discrepancies across states as it relates to the availability of adult ADHD providers, but the availability is just pretty low across the board. So it would be difficult, I think, to find somebody probably in most areas.
But especially if we think about areas of the country, or rural areas and things like that, that often have trouble getting access to healthcare more generally, those are also the states where the access to adult ADHD care wasn't looking too promising.
Meghan Beier, PhD: Is there a way for people with ADHD to find psychologists? For CBT for insomnia, for example, there are different societies that will list out that expertise or have a directory of people that specialize in that area. Do you know of anything like that that exists for ADHD?
Nicole Groves, PhD: Yes. So there is a professional directory for CHADD, C-H-A-D-D, which is an organization of folks like myself who research or treat ADHD. And there's also a lot of folks with lived experience, like caregivers of kids with ADHD and adults with ADHD. They have a provider directory, so you could see folks there.
They also often have local support groups and things like that. So it would be different than CBT for ADHD, but especially if you're new on the journey of diagnosis or treatment, or just trying to figure out what this looks like for you as an adult, I think sometimes those support groups can be helpful in finding other people who are already connected to local resources, or just finding some validation and support in that way.
Meghan Beier, PhD: Yeah, that's really helpful. I often find that talking to other people [with] similar life experiences can be almost just as powerful as working with a therapist, especially if they're giving helpful feedback.
Nicole Groves, PhD: Absolutely. I think oftentimes the sentiment that we hear is like, “Oh, I wasn't just lazy,” or, “I wasn't just a really difficult kid. There was something else going on, and now I have that framework to move forward with.” It helps depersonalize the symptoms from your character or some sort of moral standing too.
[34:14] Telehealth and Adult ADHD
Meghan Beier, PhD: Yeah. Now, maybe from your experience, or if you know of any research, please share it. Is there any difference in terms of treatment that's provided via telemedicine versus in person when you're working with somebody with ADHD?
Nicole Groves, PhD: I don't know that there's a ton of difference. I think at this point, especially post-COVID, we have a lot of evidence that shows that, for therapy at least... There are differences in prescribing guidelines and stuff like that that I don't know fully. But at least with therapy, there aren't too many differences in terms of the actual efficacy of CBT for ADHD through telemedicine or in person.
I think the primary difference there would be whatever that individual person is able to access, right? If they can only access telemedicine, then that might be better than nothing. I do know, though, that some folks prefer in person. They feel more engaged, or they feel like they'll be less tempted to multitask and things like that.
So I think, especially if you've got the flexibility of in person versus telehealth with a specific client, it might be helpful to have a conversation about what they think is best or what would be most helpful to them.
I will say the other massive benefit, in my experience of telehealth, working with folks with ADHD is that if they forget about the appointment, they don't have to travel into the appointment. You can send them the link and give them a call, and they can hop on five minutes late instead of missing the whole [session].
Meghan Beier, PhD: Yeah, absolutely. I've definitely noticed that in the people I work with who have other kinds of executive functioning issues.
Is there anything that people who are working via telemedicine should keep in mind? For example, is there any higher risk for suicide? I think you mentioned one thing, right? Is there anything that you would do differently, in terms of maybe you would call somebody who has ADHD and not just assume that they're missing the appointment for some other reason? What would you do that's maybe unique to telemedicine when you're working with somebody that has ADHD?
Nicole Groves, PhD: I think the risk is largely the same as the additional risk that you would incur with any psychiatric disorder, where you don't necessarily have the benefit of behavioral observations from the shoulders down. So you can't always tell how well-groomed people are, or things like that, but hopefully you can still track based on what you can see.
In terms of risk for suicide and things like that, my assessments for suicide risk are often pretty similar across telehealth and in person, and safety planning and things like that also doesn't necessarily change. I will say the one benefit there might be similar to the way that you can do anxiety exposures in real time through telehealth, sometimes a little bit easier and a little bit more naturalistically.
If you're doing something like managing suicide risk, you can have people identify those means and put them away with you on the call, rather than having to do that when they get home. So I think some of those risks are largely the risks that we've already grappled with and found workarounds for as a field.
For ADHD specifically, yes, I never assume that someone is intentionally missing a session unless they've contacted me beforehand. In the system that I work in, it's very easy to send a direct join link to a phone, an email, sometimes to multiple people. I always do that. I always give a phone call, just to support that memory and forgetfulness piece of things.
The other thing that I'll often talk about with folks is this idea that there are some benefits to an in-person setting, meaning that you're not necessarily going to be distracted by that notification going off on your work computer, or your kid or your pet or somebody else coming into the room.
We often have to talk with folks about not cooking dinner while you're on a telehealth call, or making sure that your car is at least parked if you have to be in it. So I think setting expectations for trying to make the telehealth environment as focused and distraction-free as possible, and then also leveraging the benefit of it, right?
On a telehealth call, you can get up and walk around if you need to, and it's not distracting to other people in the same way as it would be in person. So those are the main things that I think about: talking with people ahead of time and helping them know that they might need to plan for distraction, or they might need to plan for things like internet connectivity, and working with them, especially in those earlier sessions, as they establish that rhythm of what it means to participate in therapy.
Meghan Beier, PhD: Okay. So I've had certain patients, for example, who will be talking to me, but then I see their finger going like this, which indicates to me that they're doing something at the same time. You would call out those behaviors and talk to them about it?
Nicole Groves, PhD: Yeah, absolutely, especially if you get the sense that it interrupts their uptake in therapy. For me, it's always a balance. Some people have to join from their phone, and so if you get a call, you're going to have to swipe it away from the screen, or it might cause you to disconnect briefly or whatever.
But I think the general MO that I have is that therapy participation is a skill in and of itself, and it's not something that we're just born knowing how to do. And especially if you already have some challenges with attention, or managing your time and organizing your space, it can be really helpful to talk about those things explicitly.
It's expected, right, that you would run across some of those issues. Let's problem-solve them together, rather than, on the clinician side, feeling like, “Oh, this person isn't really engaged,” or they don't care, or having some of those unhelpful thoughts on our side too. It's that mutual understanding that therapy participation is a skill that we build together over time.
[43:13] Session Notes and External Structure
Meghan Beier, PhD: Okay. Very helpful. One of the other things that I typically do with people that I know have cognitive challenges is I will take notes throughout the session, goals that they're talking about, and then I will send them a goal list at the end of every session. I know not every psychologist or therapist wants to do that, or maybe they [see] that as doing too much work. What's your thought about that? Do you do that with people that have ADHD?
Nicole Groves, PhD: Absolutely. I do that, frankly, for my own memory as well. When you start to see so many people and you're talking about the same stuff, it's really helpful to take notes, and I always try to take notes in a way that it wouldn't bother me if the client saw them. So a lot of times I'm not necessarily doing a lot of extra work to send things to people.
And if that's not a part of your practice that's already routine, and the idea of that is so aversive to you that you're like, “Well, I'm not seeing people with ADHD then,” we could find a workaround for that. The other thing that I'll often do is, as I'm writing things down, I might have a conversation with people about what is most helpful for them to remember and recall.
So we might take a moment in the session, and we're both physically writing things down, or they might have a note open in their phone and type the main points in there. It gives you time, I think, to model the skill of writing down what you hear in real time in a way that supports your recollection and your follow-through.
And it gives people time to practice that skill while also knowing that they have a fallback, and they can get your notes too, to supplement theirs. So I usually try to do a bit of both, where I'm asking them to take notes or to track things in whatever way is going to make the most sense to them, but then I'm also doing that and often sending it along.
Meghan Beier, PhD: Okay. Really helpful. It's almost like you're doing some cognitive rehab with them, training them to do it, but also providing that external structure for if they aren't quite there yet.
Nicole Groves, PhD: Exactly. Yeah.
[45:57] Clinician Hesitancy and Bias
Meghan Beier, PhD: So in your paper, getting back to the paper, and correct any of this that isn't right, I think it noted that many providers may view ADHD as a low priority or avoid these types of clients. Maybe they view them as having more procrastination or low follow-through, things like that. Can you talk to this piece of it?
Nicole Groves, PhD: Yeah. So there's certainly still, I think, some stigma or bias against ADHD among professionals. What I will say is that I have some hope as I see these things becoming more a part of our cultural knowledge. I think that a lot of psychologists and mental health professionals are following suit and reexamining maybe some of those biases and things like that.
The idea of ADHD as this low-risk, maybe even low-reward population to work with is frankly probably another bias. I think anybody who works with ADHD across the lifespan will tell you that it's certainly not a low-risk disorder. And if you are interested in people with significant challenges, and you want to work on things other than how you manage a calendar, you'll have the opportunity to do those things with adults with ADHD.
And I think the other piece here is understanding that, absolutely, it makes sense to me that if someone is coming to you and telling you that their primary problem is suicidality, and you're able and willing to treat that, then maybe that gets prioritized in terms of weight above ADHD.
But there also may be more below the tip of the iceberg of somebody who says that they're coming in for ADHD. They probably also have comorbidities and other things affecting their life. So we shouldn't write it off as, “Eh, they'll be all right. They can wait longer. They can figure it out.”
And the other, I think maybe it's a reassurance or a challenge that I give to people, is that if you've worked with folks with really any psychopathology, you've worked with folks who have trouble taking what they know they, quote unquote, “should do” and following through with it. Or you've worked with folks who are having difficulty with motivation or attention or impulsivity, because those symptoms are so ubiquitous.
So yes, there are differences with adult ADHD, and you've already seen these symptoms in your day-to-day practice. So you've probably figured out how to work with them.
Meghan Beier, PhD: Yeah, it's a really good reminder. And also, I think, giving people confidence that they can. I think if people don't have specialized training, they maybe assume that they can't, but they have the skills in order to work with somebody like this.
Nicole Groves, PhD: Yeah, exactly. And that's one of the things that we found in follow-up, is that the primary hesitance that psychologists have is feeling like, “I don't have the knowledge, I don't have the training to work with adult ADHD,” or feeling low self-efficacy: “I don't know that what I do is going to be helpful for them.”
And there is often that tension where I often say that, yes, right, people with ADHD, just like people with any other disorder, deserve expertise in their presenting problem, but they also deserve access. And sometimes there is a trade-off where you may not be the adult ADHD person in your clinic, but you probably still have skills that would be helpful to these folks.
[50:56] Visibility and the PSYPACT Directory
Meghan Beier, PhD: Yeah. That's really great. Now, switching gears a little bit, I was talking to somebody recently who was asking about the PSYPACT directory, and asking, “What's the main challenge here? Is it that people don't know that the directory exists, so they're not putting themselves on it? Is it that patients don't even know that they can see people across state lines, so they don't know to look for us? Is this a marketing issue? Are there other barriers?” And again, you may not have all of the knowledge, and probably more research is needed. So with all of that caveat, what have been your thoughts, or conversations around this with colleagues?
Nicole Groves, PhD: Yeah. So with all of those caveats in mind, I think everything that you said is probably an issue. From our experience combing through things, we were often going off of the PSYPACT directory onto other platforms, like Psychology Today, to try to figure out what people actually did, or having to track them down through LinkedIn or other sources.
So I think a lot of folks are just on there with their bare-bones identifying information, or relatively limited information. I also think that there's likely a big gap in the general public's knowledge that PSYPACT exists, and so when you're searching for a therapist, you don't necessarily have to search within your home state, especially if you want or are planning to do telemedicine.
And I think, in general, psychologists sometimes have a marketing issue, where we're really not great at letting people know what we do and what we can do, or where we can practice. So I do think there's a gap in that marketing piece of it as well, in letting people know what you can do and where you can practice, and being sure that that information is reaching wide enough that somebody who has maybe done an evaluation or talked to their primary care doctor, and the recommendation that they get is something like, “Yeah, you should do therapy, maybe something like CBT,” can find the resources that are going to be most helpful to them when they Google that.
Meghan Beier, PhD: Okay. Excellent. [My] husband actually works in website design, and he's worked for a couple of therapy practices, and has said most people don't know how to use their website for marketing.
Nicole Groves, PhD: Absolutely. And especially if you're trying to market to people who maybe have difficulty with sustained attention, or working themselves through tedious or frustrating tasks. Going through Psychology Today profiles and things like that, it's tedious and often frustrating. And so people are more likely to give up if it's not marketed to them in a way that strikes while the iron's hot, so to speak.
[54:38] Workforce Expansion and ADHD Coaching
Meghan Beier, PhD: Right. Okay, I know we're coming towards the end here, so I have two more questions. The first one is, I think your paper raised workforce expansion, so really helping people who are master's level get the training that they need to work with ADHD. And I think you even mentioned ADHD coaching. I think all of those are really interesting, especially if the need is there. Can you tell me more about that?
Nicole Groves, PhD: Yeah. So what we do know is that a lot of these interventions can be effectively implemented with fidelity by people who are master's-level therapists, or even folks who are still in training, which is reassuring. Obviously, there's also that model where, especially if you're still in training, you often have formal supervision or consultation and things like that to support.
ADHD coaching is an interesting field in that it has naturally taken up some of the space that's left and some of the gap that we have in formal therapy services. And we don't have a lot of information about what that looks like. The information that we do have is that it's probably a very heterogeneous practice.
We really don't necessarily know what coaching looks like. And the other piece of it here is that, of course, there are those of us with healthcare licenses who are not the best at our jobs, and there is a baseline of regulation and safety. That doesn't exist in the coaching field in the way that, you know, I have a license, you can look me up, you can see if I've had any disciplinary action or things like that, and there's a baseline understanding of the kind of degree that I have, or the kind of training that I have, to be able to call myself a psychologist. That doesn't exist for coaching.
So there are plenty of wonderful coaches out there. They're a very motivated and often very personable workforce. So I think they're already playing a role, and there probably is a role for them in the future. And it's not something that I'm actively recommending to people yet, because of those concerns around regulation and safety, and you really don't know what you're going to get with coaching.
Meghan Beier, PhD: So if there was some way to ensure that they had certain types of training or certain kinds of certifications and things like that, maybe. But it's a pretty unregulated field, [with] a lot of variability, and it's very hard to know if you're working with somebody who really understands and knows how to be most useful.
Nicole Groves, PhD: Yeah, exactly.
[58:19] Resources for Clinicians
Meghan Beier, PhD: Okay. And final question. If people have been intrigued by this conversation and they want to do more work with ADHD, are there any types of resources or trainings that you think they should look into, or researchers that they should look up? Just a couple of things that could be useful for those individuals who are interested.
Nicole Groves, PhD: I always direct people, professionals, clients, really anybody, to CHADD, C-H-A-D-D.org. It's a wonderful springboard for pretty much any questions that you have about ADHD evaluation, treatment, and basic research related to ADHD. They've got webinars and podcasts and people with lived experience, and so they're a great resource, I think, if you're looking to dip your toes in the water and see what else you can do.
If you already provide care for adults with ADHD, make sure that it's clear that you do that on your websites and whatever other materials you have, so that people are aware of what's already out there. But I think CHADD is often a great resource to get yourself started in the world of ADHD.
Meghan Beier, PhD: Well, thank you so much for your time. This was really helpful and insightful. I learned a lot, and I hope the people who are listening learned a lot. I truly appreciate your time.
Nicole Groves, PhD: Great. Thank you.
[1:00:03] Closing
Meghan Beier, PhD: If you like our show, please like, subscribe, or leave a review. This helps others find out about us. Find Empathy provides continuing education. If you would like to learn more about our courses, please click the link in the show notes or visit learn.findempathy.com. While our education is free, for example, listening to this podcast, the proceeds we receive from continuing education go to support the maintenance of our website and the development of new content.
Finally, please know that the opinions expressed by the experts today are their own. We are not financially supported by any of the businesses or resources described in today's podcast. Additionally, any advertising that is published on the episode is chosen by our podcast hosting service and not by Find Empathy.
The content provided today is for educational purposes only. Please seek the guidance of your doctor or mental health professional for any questions you might have regarding your own health or medical condition. Thank you so much for listening, and we look forward to you joining us in the next episode.